Web vs. Native: Which App is Best for Your Strategy?

7 years ago

Web Apps vs. Native Apps: Which is best for your company's strategy?

There has been a significant change in consumer focus from what’s on the Web, to the apps on our mobile devices. Businesses are already aware of the need to adapt to mobile. One of the first decisions to make on the app development journey is whether to simply build a web app or to invest in developing a native mobile app. This is where the web app vs. native app debate begins…

There are many ways to deliver content through a mobile device. Depending on your business objectives and overall goals, this decision could make or break the success of your mobile strategy; there several factors to consider. Here is a brief snapshot of the advantages and disadvantages of web apps, native apps and hybrid apps, and how to pick the right one for your business.

Web Apps

Web apps are accessible through a mobile devices web browser. These types of apps are basically a web page, or series of web pages, that are designed to work on a mobile screen. Being device agnostic, this “write-once-run-anywhere” approach to app development produces apps that can be opened with any modern mobile browser and thus work on multiple devices.

Pros

Web apps look and feel very much like native mobile apps. An important advantage of the “write-once-run-anywhere” development process is that distribution and support are much easier. Web apps are:

Easier to develop,
Easier to maintain and support – quick to fix bugs,
Relatively inexpensive,
One app built for all platforms – as long as it can run on a browser, and
Don’t take up storage on a users device.

Cons

Even though a web app can be straightforward and quick to build, they are often oversimplified and don’t have access to all native features on a mobile device. Other disadvantages include:

They need a browser to run,
Users have to type in the URL of the app instead of the app sitting on the home screen – this can result in a poor user experience,
Performance is often slower,
They cannot leverage the full extent of native device functionality e.g. camera, calendar, geolocation,
There are limitations with offline storage and security, and
Web apps are generally less interactive and intuitive compared to native apps.

Native Apps

When you think of mobile apps, you are probably thinking of a native app. Native apps are specific to a given mobile platform (e.g. iOS or Android) and use the development tools and language that the respective platform supports. As a result, these types of apps are downloaded directly onto the device itself, usually via an app marketplace. Native mobile apps are usually designed for a very specific and narrow strategic purpose.

Pros

Native apps generally look and perform the best. Developing native mobile apps often results in quality, speed and the opportunity to leverage mobile features and functionality. Optimising the user experience is a key advantage of native apps, as they are developed specifically for the device’s platform. Native apps are:

Faster and more responsive because they are built to run on a specific platform,
Often designed much lighter and as such have the best performance,
Distributed in app stores and therefore are readily available where users are searching,
More interactive, intuitive and run much smoother in terms of user input and output,
Able to access and leverage the full native feature and functionality set of their given platform,
Functional offline – once a native app has been downloaded onto a device an internet connection is not required,
Better for user experience – the flow is more natural as there are specific UI standards for each platform, and
A native app sits on a mobile devices home screen – providing a consistent brand presence.

Cons

Native apps are more expensive to develop. Even though they offer higher performance and better user experience, they also take more resources, skills and time to develop. Other disadvantages include:

They have to go through different approval processes for each operating system the app is developed for,
They involve difficult developer languages – you either need experienced native app developers in your team or to hire a development agency,
There are longer development and testing cycles, and
They need to be designed and developed separately for each platform – unless you implement a cross-platform app development approach

Hybrid Apps

Hybrid apps make it possible to embed web apps inside a native ‘shell’, allowing it to work across platforms but behave like native apps. More specifically, this native app container allows web apps to access and leverage native platform features and device hardware. Just like native, hybrid apps are installed on the mobile device. In a nutshell, hybrid apps are considered to combine the best, and worst, elements of native and web apps.

Pros

Hybrid apps have potential, as there is a benefit in not having to build and maintain apps for separate native platforms. Other advantages include:

They are built on web technology, and therefore, are much easier and faster to develop compared to native apps,
This means they are also generally cheaper to develop – providing that custom functionality is kept to a minimum,
They can also access a device’s native features,
Like web apps, you can develop once for all platforms, and
Unlike web, browser access is not required giving them a more native feel.

Cons

With hybrid apps, you have to contend with issues that stem from both native and hybrid systems. Not only this, the user experience is often impacted with a hybrid app as, similarly to web apps, you cannot customise the app based on the device platform. Hybrid apps also:

Generally have a slower performance compared to native apps – the app loads in WebView,
Unsurprisingly, are more expensive than standard web apps,
Remain less interactive than native apps, and
Cannot be customised to the same extent as native apps – the more customisation required, the more expensive the hybrid app, the more development should steer towards native.

The Best Approach…

The debate around which type of app is best is still relevant today as the lines between the three approaches become increasingly blurred. There are many factors that play a part in your mobile strategy, such as your team’s development skills, required device functionality, offline capability etc., all of which must be taken into account. Therefore, the decision to build either a native, web or hybrid mobile app should be based on your business objectives. Before jumping into app development, consider the following factors:

How fast you need to develop the app,
The quality of the user experience you want your app to have,
The complexity of the features you need for your app to work, and
Your budget and resources (developer skills etc).

You may also find the following resources useful:

Native App vs. Web App vs. Hybrid App

Generally, it is best to stick to a native approach and not sacrifice on the design elements that are unique to each platform. As such, most companies with sufficient resources will invest in native mobile app development. However, if you want the best of native and the cost-effective benefits of cross-platform functionality then consider leveraging a hybrid development approach. On the other hand, if you want to get something to market fast and cheap and aren’t too concerned about the overall user experience, then a web app may be the way to go.

Have you found the right app development platform to execute your mobile strategy?

With the huge drive in mobile app downloads expected to continue, now is a good time to seriously consider your company’s mobile strategy. At Liquid State, we understand the importance of implementing enterprise app software as a part of corporate strategy. Our platform empowers businesses to build native, code-free, cross-platform apps for a variety of business functions.

With Liquid State, you can manage and deliver the right communications to the right people on the right devices. To chat with a professional about your future mobile app needs, contact us today.